book
free will
Evidence
Citations (73)
The most important part of EVERYONE IS YOU PUSHED OUT (EIYPO) — I think that what I will say in the following lines has to be reminded as much as possible in the manifesting exes and partners communities. Manifesting a person is not only easy, it is effortle…
Attachment Theory & Free Will? — Dear all, I'm very intrigued by the relationship between attachment theory (&, I supposed, any psychological theory) & free-will. They seem to me to slightly conflict. Certainly, it is a difficult p…
The issue of Free Will
Specific Person (SP) Manifestation: No Magic, No Supernatural Forces. Just Proven Science — Hi everyone, It’s been a long time since I last posted, and honestly it was overdue. I keep seeing the same recycled LOA bullshit everywhere. Endless manifestation porn, more unqualified people calli…
The Astrology of the 21st Century — Which major transits up until now have coincided with major world events and more importantly which future transits should we be looking out for. Where is the world headed and how much of it is in our…
Why do some parents expect you to take care of them(because that's why they made you after all) and at the same time try to fuck over your life so that you have no resources with which to help them? — Seriously, wouldn't it be more sound if you would help your child(or atleast try to not fuck over their life) and then they would help you out of their own will not only because they want to but also …
How Neville Manifested His Marriage - Do Not Meddle In The Middle. — **For Those Who Need...** From Neville's Audio Lecture. The verbatim from Neville's Lecture (*Updated*) : *“When I decided to marry the lady who now bears my name I applied this principle. At the t…
3 month lock in challenge? Done. Next 1? FREE WILL — Hi lovelies, Near the start of the year, I did a 3 month lock in challenge that is ending soon. My affirmation: Isn’t it wonderful. Some wins: \- visited Brazil for the first time & saw the para…
April 03, 2026 - Weekly FAQ and Beginner Q&A Thread | If you are new to Neville, please post your questions here! How do I manifest X? What does Y mean? — Feel free to ask any type of question on this thread. More importantly, feel free to answer questions that have been asked! Additionally, please refrain from posting multiple questions in the subredd…
April 03, 2026 - Weekly Simple Success Stories (+Neville FAQ) — **Please post your simple success stories in the comments.** [*Old Weekly Success Stories Threads*](https://www.reddit.com/r/NevilleGoddard/search?q=author%3AAutomoderator+title%3ASuccess&restrict_sr…
Sarah believed in a prison planet teaching. What Higher Self showed her during soul journey was amazing and empowering — Heads up - not native English speaker here. I am sharing what I learned in one healing soul journey I facilitated, in case it helps someone who carry this heavy teaching on their shoulders. Sarah c…
Are Astroligical predicitions always accurate? — If astrology predicts fixed outcomes from your birth chart, then where does free will fit in—and what other factors actually shape what happens in our lives? Question to the experts out here.
Doubt on Free Will, Meditations — Does Meditations by Marcus Aurelius draw a bridge for the readers to interpret the existence of free will on their own because at some parts of his book he talks about Nature or a Rational source dete…
Stoic free will versus determinism — I recently posted this comment on a question regarding free will in Stoicism. I’d like any refinements or corrections to improve my understanding of free will and determinism in Stoic thought. The St…
Time is fake; there is nothing but you. — Shifting, dimensional jumping, Neville Goddard, law of assumption/attraction, magick, etc. all essentially talk about the same thing: Embody the person (or entity) you want to be. This post is a bit…
How to break the cycle? - seeking the abuse — I was a CSA victim unofficially I never mentioned it when I was in state custody only the known/visible abuse was said. I find when I get triggered or feel like I need to feel something or am stressed…
Anyone else’s mom say rude/mean things about people who are close to you? — I had an argument with my mom today because she kept bad mouthing my friends, family, and my partner. I’m very close to everyone and I know that they care and love for me genuinely. But my mom seems t…
Neville Goddard: the Complete Reader Audible Chapter Titles — A life-changing investment. I listen, then listen again, and again. The chapters in the Amazon Audible file aren't titled. I wrote this out over several listenings. I find it helpful. I thought this g…
April 10, 2026 - Weekly FAQ and Beginner Q&A Thread | If you are new to Neville, please post your questions here! How do I manifest X? What does Y mean? — Feel free to ask any type of question on this thread. More importantly, feel free to answer questions that have been asked! Additionally, please refrain from posting multiple questions in the subredd…
April 10, 2026 - Weekly Simple Success Stories (+Neville FAQ) — **Please post your simple success stories in the comments.** [*Old Weekly Success Stories Threads*](https://www.reddit.com/r/NevilleGoddard/search?q=author%3AAutomoderator+title%3ASuccess&restrict_sr…
being watched by parents at night — I am 16 years old living with my mom and her girlfriend (only my mom has parental rights over me) My mom informed me that her partner and the neighbours saw me the other night around 1 am standing in…
Free will vs timelines — I see that this community is divided between the people who believe you can manifest specific people's attitudes (e.g SPs) because you'd be simply changing between the infinite amount of timelines or …
Index — \[Updated: December 30th, 2021.\] Links with an asterisk beside them recently added. ​ **Books** [The Power of Your Subconscious Mind - Joseph Murphy](http://www.logoscenter.org/downloads/T…
We actually do live in a magnetic universe. But you can believe whatever you want, because we also live in a free will universe. And Humans will take any opportunity to draw lines of division between …
I'm of the opinion that there is no free will, chemicals move in your brain and then a decision happens, not vice versa. Just like lungs expand to take in air for you to breathe and the stomach digest…
My simplified view (derived from a ton of research with about 80 finished books on AT, Trauma, Neurochemistry, Therapy, Mindfulness, etc) is that until one has awakened to own insecure attachment and …
Free will is a fundational lense through which we experiment the world. We have the impression of free will. We hold ourself and other responsible for their actions. It seems impossible to think the w…
If you've ever had trauma, especially with a somatic response, you can consider attachment to be a form of trauma and it doesn't affect free will. Some parts of us aren't directly controllable, but t…
I'm definitely not a philosopher by any means, but here are my thoughts. The article references previous research by Monroe & Malle (2009), where it's said that people's concept of free will consists …
I agree. Free will, in the classical sense of making choices independently of external influence or determinism, can only be exercised by those who have freed themselves of their own emotional baggage…
Interesting thought. Out of curiosity, don't securely attached people also have "patterns" that they follow? Or would you say secure attachment alone is not enough for free will?
1. It seems like the study you linked investigates a slightly different topic than what your post is about. The study is investigating the psychological relationship between attachment anxiety, attach…
I think this is an interesting question that I have often thought of. I didn't read the study, but in general I don't think anyone should think of "attachment style" as an immutable characteristic - …
I agree with you. Until the individual who has a disregulated nervous system can work on themselves, free will is non existent. Their biology is in threat detection and survival mode which leads to sh…
I don't know, but whenever I decide to believe in free will (or the illusion of free will because I clearly don't believe in it) it makes me much more successful, gives me an ego boost and makes me at…
You can only control your own behaviour, you cannot control the outcome of a situation where another person has free will. It's a hard pill to swallow because anxious attachers feel uncomfortable with…
Thank you for saying this because it means I must be steadfast in my beliefs and it is on me if I want to experience a different reality with him in it. That it isn’t like he has free will to be any o…
Forgive me for being thick, but I think I just became even more confused. I read both posts and just finished reading the link to the post by Marsh273, you shared. I have read quite a few of them in …
I'm going to take a crack at this using critical thinking alone. *" The very concepts of "beginning," "created," and "suddenly exist" are all products of our three-dimensional perception, where we ex…
Beautifully said. I believe so too. Also the infinite past basically 99.9999999% pre-determined all the actions of yours. If free will existed, we would be able to do magic, but we can't. We are limit…
Hello everyone, I need help. I've already manifest a SP, but it's hot and cold and we're just in a situationship. What can I do? I've taken a few courses and each one told me something different. Pl…
We all have free will and you can't change another's as far as I know
Ok so basic thing to understand, no astro experience necessary, is that eclipse seasons happen twice a year. Our first eclipse season is basically the entire month of February. The next one is Augus…
Everything is nice at first but time and time again, Balance! Balance is always key. Someone being obsessed is not balance, eventually that person who is looking for someone obsessed will feel smother…
First I’d like to say that I’m sorry, I know this would be confusing for anyone in this situation. Things go well 7 years ago and again in present day, but she shuts you out. To be fair to her, she d…
Please don't misunderstand. At no point did I say things have to be perfect to date. That's obviously an absurd position. Instead, I'm pointing out that you're using relationships as a way to try to…
big question, but the historical pattern is clear enough to sketch. **what's already happened:** - **pluto in capricorn (2008-2024)**: global financial crisis, rise of authoritarianism, surveillance…
so i've been looking at the uranus-pluto square from 2012-2015 and how it coincided with the arab spring and the whole occupy wall street movement - it's like this massive awakening to the fact that t…
Free will. Astrology is only the natal promise. No two people will do the same thing with that promise. Nature vs. Nurture—esp with twins of the opposite sec. Girls are raised differently than boys.
Heres the First real answer, the ones above are all Kind of meme: Are you maybe afraid or have any Fear relating to this topic (aliens, Grey’s). If so, this was a fear test by the larger consciousnes…
I almost refuse to watch rom-coms. The dramatic gestures of love are so far removed from anything I've experienced. I felt I had grown an expectation that wasn't in alignment with reality. So, I don't…
I would both be okay with this, and a little bit concerned. If there are people among us who have the ability to just control us, then we've lost our free will, have we not? Now, if they don't do a…
u know in Mahabharata at 17th day when karna was fighting arjuna he had training from lord parshuram and he had bow given by lord parshuram , he was son Surya Dev ashirvad yet he loss and it all boile…
All of this sounds amazing. Sorry again if I seemed critical. As im sure you know, there are some people out there who try and set their clients up to becoming dependent on them. I definitely dont fee…
My sister is an Aries Moon with Venus in Aries to feed the flames. Her greediness made her sue her own family for money. It's the worst of the worst. But it's not her CHART'S fault. We are responsibl…
I played baseball as a kid, but eventually got so mad because I just could never hit a ball. Instead of seeing my pain and helping me practice, she scolded me for losing my temper and suggested quitti…
We all have free will to choose...They may have been yearning to but figured the best action was not to come back..
Thank you! And even IF we had chosen abuse, the abusers still would have abused us of THEIR free will. So even if we would have chosen abuse (for what ever reason), it would have been enough to just i…
For 10 years I told myself I chose my office job. Good pay, stable career, the responsible thing to do. It wasn't until much later I realized I never actually questioned it. I just absorbed what "choo…
Such a good way to put it. I’m her belonging and I think she hates me so much cause I do have free will and I’m not what I’m supposed to be, as her belonging.
This is one of my favorite rabbit holes in lucid dreaming. That recursive moment where you realize the DC's reaction to your insight is ALSO you... it's like holding two mirrors facing each other. I …
freeloaders end up last. anything worth its salt in this world is never for free.... u will keep suffering at manifestation... sorry but i wish u become wise and remember you get what you give to univ…
I have free will. You go right ahead! The creators knew they were making an occult topic/ ‘pseudoscience’ science website. That if you know how to use it, can be very valuable bc the original ppl who …
I know it's meant to be complimentary and supportive, but I think messaging like that to kids is so damaging. Y'know how to change the world? Be the best YOU that you can be. Who gives a fuck about a…
Fascinating, I’ve heard angels will genuinely assist you if given permission and demons more so try to manipulate and find legal loopholes to have you sign over your free will.
Helping your kids out from your own free will bc you want to see them succeed would be the way to go. But unfortunately we’re not dealing with sane people. They are only in it for themselves and for t…
Nope! It does sound like that, and it's what I thought at first too. STS is more about control, domination, manipulating others for your own benefit. STS entities have no qualms about infringing on th…
I’m very sorry you are in this situation under the control of such abusive parents who are taking advantage of your life threatening illness to dictate your life. I’m also very happy that you have suc…
My experiences are completely different to yours. I do not expect any gifts from my parents ever. I live with them. On the topic of being hypocrites, that is very common. Gifts should not be given w…
You saw your astral body leaving your physical body. Nicely done! You saw your astral body. The "you" in that sentence is energy organized around awareness. That's the definition of a spirit. Spirit…
Your soul chooses. No one gets sent anywhere they dont want to go. This reality is based in free will.
But don’t you understand that if you have to remind a grownass man or women to shower or wash their clothes before a date that portends major problems down the line. And you do make the rules. That’…
Well, those are some heavy words. Any concrete arguments for your free will theory?